Discussion about this post

User's avatar
sampa's avatar

I voted none of the above because I don’t know, and that’s okay.

Expand full comment
Abigail Hardy's avatar

I voted none of the above. I have a Christian faith, and won’t start waxing lyrical - but my firmly held and strongly rooted belief system does not coalesce with the traditional ideas of heaven and hell even a tiny bit. For these, I believe there is no Biblical or truly human basis. When read properly and in context, that hell isn’t mentioned in the Bible. Neither can I possibly buy into the idea that we float away to some unembodied realm. How quintessentially bleak and frankly, boring. Karma is in and of itself a detestably bleak concept (I could elaborate if pushed, but the “do good get good” idea of energy reduced to its most disrespectfully shallow representation is simply neither true nor edifying, and in the end oppressive). I think we consistently fail to grasp what the reality of heaven might be, but suffice to say I am sure it is solid, true, breathtakingly like coming home and so far removed from “good people playing harps on clouds” as to be unrecognisable to the peddlars of that image. We shall see clearly, we shall be free - but I think the idea of death as portal is also a misrepresentation - we focus too much on the death. What about the power of life and defeat of death, in the end rendering the latter almost useless in the conversation? What about a continuum of beauty that has already begun, and to which we can contribute meaningfully in this life, in a way that reverberates in heaven now and will make lasting connections to that realm so that something feels familiar yet completely unexpected once we get to inhabit it?

It is 4.40 am and I have to feed the baby. Please excuse the ramblings. Abi

Expand full comment
33 more comments...

No posts