Should we re-invent allopathic medicine?
an impromptu short post exploring whether or not we should try and preserve modern western industrial "medicine" systems
Some people (such as Toby Rogers) think that allopathic medicine needs to be reinvented.
While I do recognize that some of allopathic medicine’s contributions to trauma care are noteworthy and worth preserving in some format, I also see that at it’s heart, the Germ Theory mentality that pervades the medical academic establishment (no matter how well intended by individuals in those systems) is not about healing, but is in fact, antithetical to life.
The machine thinking of Allopathic medicine which treats the human body as a molecular machine in need of being kept sterile and well greased by an array of chemicals and synthetic lab made substances is like the modern government funded environmentalist program that tries to quantify everything down to carbon units, obsessing over limiting them or sequestering them with more machines, while avoiding/ignoring the fact that it is machines that decimated the environment in the first place and continue to (whether they are lithium powered or gas powered) and not even beginning to take into account other variables such as the massive influence that old growth forests (or the lack thereof) have on hydrological cycles as well as carbon cycles.
It is like the machine thinking of the Big Ag Chemical companies and conventional GMO monoculture farmer who, when faced with diminishing returns due to soil erosion, nutrient leaching, desertification, decreasing mineral and nutritional content in crops (due to soil depletion brought about by extractive and exploitative farming practices) and facing herbicide resistant “weeds”, decides to double down and create even more powerful machines to till the soil harder, faster, inculcate the crop plants with an ever more potent array of synthetic chemicals and petroleum based NPK to keep them alive (on the equivalent of a combination of life support and hard drugs) and decides to create and use even more potent biocides and herbicides to kill all life in the soil in order to squeeze increasingly meager returns out of an abused and dying landscape.
Those are systems of machine thinking, treating living complex systems that are defined and only capable of being healthy, stable and resilient by the myriad symbiotic relationships woven within and around them as simple machines. Both involve one dimensional ways of thinking attempting to understand, heal and make whole multi-dimensional entities.
The “trust the science” proclaiming doctor attempting to treat anti-biotic drug resistant bacteria infected wounds with more and more powerful anti-biotic drugs is like the techno-optimist self-proclaimed environmental activist cheering for more machines (perhaps lithium powered machines) to be built which are supposed to solve the problems created by the previous machines.
The masked up, A.I. powered intubated breathing machine assisted, intravenously antibiotic juiced up hospital industry and psychotic cult like vaccine industry that claims to continue to provide the most safe and effective way to keep the bad guys out of the human body fails to take into account that human health is not achieved via maximizing sterility and control, but rather is a reflection of the health of the community of life that one exists within, and that exists within us.
I advocate leaving most of Allopathic medicine behind, and only taking what we can carry with us as individuals and local communities with the tools at our disposal while simultaneously learning from (and building upon) the more holistic healing modalities of our ancient indigenous ancestors (yes we all have them). I advocate planting the seeds for radical decentralization of our access to pathways for healing so that we can embrace health sovereignty as individuals and communities living within a web of reciprocal relationships with the more than human world which serve to increase not only our own resilience, but also the resilience and abundance of the natural world around us.
The Allopathic medicine industrial complex is corrupt to the core and incapable of being “re-invented” for several of it’s most core aspects are faulty, counter-intuitive to life thriving and they incentivize corruption.
At it’s foundation, Allopathic medicine is built upon a reductionist, deterministic and atheist view of the universe, our place in it, biology and health. Thus, no amount of “re-inventing” of that inherently flawed, irreparably incapable and inevitably stagnating/inaccurate lens can make it into something worth giving to future generations. If we were to incorporate the truth of our eternal spiritual essence into the medical system it would no longer be Allopathic medicine, but something else all together.
Rather than try to antibiotic injection our way out of an antibiotic drug created infection or industrial scale lithium mine our way out of an industrial civilization created ecological crisis perhaps we should take a step back to ponder what our ancient indigenous ancestors might have done to address these challenges if they were to look through their animate worldview lens, which operated through a web of reciprocity, to live life perpetually giving and gracefully receiving gifts, providing medicine for the body, mind and soul and nourishment to the broader community of which we are an intrinsic part.
The industrial western medical system may have helped carry our culture to where it is today, however, where it brought us is not a good place. Allopathic medicine is a broken wagon laying on the wide, jagged and charred road that leads towards an ugly unlivable future. Re-inventing or repairing it would only provide a vehicle to carry us further towards a technocratic dystopian hellscape and it is a vehicle that should be abandoned and left behind.
In order to embark on a path towards a future with living in we have to trail blaze a path off the wide and well worn road and into the pathless wilderness where one can only carry that which is really important with them and one has to rely on their own set of skills, knowledge and available tools to deal with challenges on the path.
Embarking off the well worn road is not easy at first, leaving the familiar linear smoothed out trajectory which the priests of modernity promise will deliver us to a “safe and effective” future utopia (if we just keep “trusting the science” and doubling down on machine thinking) and instead having to lift our gaze to honestly assess the path before our feet, take responsibility for each step and plan to fulfill our own hopes and dreams for the future. It is through forging a direct reciprocal relationship with the land that provides us with medicine that we might reach beyond the seemingly impassable mountains of possibility to a place where we might unlock the memory of our ancient indigenous souls and remember the importance of place based wisdom.
The Anishinaabe Prophecy Of The Seventh Fire speaks of how there would come a time when humans would neglect their sacred connection to the living Earth and we would face a fork in the road. One of the paths is soft and green and the other is charred, jagged and burnt.
I personally see allopathic medicine industry and germ theory dogmas as obvious aspects of the path that leads to a charred, jagged and burnt place.
The prophecy says that there will come a time when people of all colors and creeds who seek to embark down the green path together must first look back to the teachings and the wisdom of their ancestors, to choose as they did, to nurture a symbiotic relationship with the land and embrace a reverence for the living Earth (which will provide them the guidance they on the path forward).
I believe that in many ways, each of us stands at that fork in the road that the Seventh Fire prophecy describes, right now.
The post above was my response to this note:
What do you think everyone, should we try and reinvent allopathic medicine?
If so, how so? And what would continue to define it as such after the transformation you might suggest for that system has taken place?
Thanks in advance for taking the time to read and comment to share your thoughts.
I just discovered your substack. Love this topic. Been reading up on the history of medicine (both allo and alternative) and my impression right now is that allo has always been very destructive and built on lies. That changed in the early 20th century when some good science was able to move conventional medicine into noted effectiveness in certain areas. With the liars and cheaters now having taken over (both science and medicine) we've moved past peak medicine and are sliding.
Cannot be reinvented, and would be a waste of effort. I am hoping that acute care will hang on, that's where allo medicine shines (provided you can defend yourself from stupid or unnecessary interventions). I am focused on moving on, and learning as much as I can about chronic issues and various maladies and annoyances that crop up as one moves through life, most of which do not need allo doctors (who know very little about them anyway) but do need shared information among sufferers about what works. There is too much crap on the alternative side as well; too many people accepting hype. Needs collaborative sifting. :-)
I used to think that conventional medicine would open itself up to alternative practices, but have of late realized that was a pipe dream. And it's better so... we need a variety of systems, not da One Truth. Allo medicine was always totalitarian, "we know best and you know nothing," even in the days when they were worse at healing than many a folk healer or midwife. Thank you for hoeing this row!!!
In addition to trauma/ER doctors, id throw in radiologists and pathologists. Those last two, for the most part, are diagnostic fields and fall into the umbrella of information gathering.